Philosophical Explorations

TitleCan Pyrrhonists act normally?
Publication TypeJournal Article
Year of Publication2012
AuthorsWieland, JWillem
JournalPhilosophical Explorations
Volume15
Number3
Pagination227–289
ISSN1386-9795
Abstract

Pyrrhonism is the view that we should suspend all our beliefs in order to be rational and reach peace of mind. One of the main objections against this view is that it makes action impossible. One cannot suspend all beliefs and act normally at once. Yet, the question is: What is it about actions that they require beliefs? This issue has hardly been clarified in the literature. This is a bad situation, for if the objection fails and it turns out that the Pyrrhonists found a way to secure peace of mind, we better know the details. In the following I take up this systematic query, and show how the objection can be made precise. Despite Sextus Empiricus' ingenious appearance/reality distinction, which is to insure Pyrrhonism in this, I eventually argue that a life by appearances is quite unlike a normal life.

DOI10.1080/13869795.2012.696133
Citation Key2964109